Science You Can Use: Some obese women struggle with breastfeeding, but new research suggests it’s not all about physiology.

The other day I was doing some looking back at the research on breastfeeding in 2012, and a couple of themes immediately jumped out at me.

One was the large number of studies on mother-to-child transmission of HIV – a topic of tremendous importance in the developing world, as this remains a significant source of new infections.

The second topic was the effect of maternal obesity on breastfeeding.

For some time research has drawn a link between maternal obesity and breastfeeding problems.  But with the recent rise in obesity among Americans – an estimated 1 in 5 women of childbearing age – there has been a big increase in research on this topic.

Much of the research from 2012 connects the two dots (maternal obesity and breastfeeding outcomes):

Maternal and Child Nutrition:  This review found that obese women are less likely to intend to breastfeed and initiate breastfeeding, that they breastfeed for shortened duration, have more milk supply problems, have delayed lactogenesis II (“milk coming in”).

Pediatrics:  This study found that mothers who were obese were less likely to meet their breastfeeding intention.

Minerva Ginecologica (Italian):  This study found that the incidence of breast-feeding was significantly lower in overweight and obese women compared with lower weight women.

This relationship looks pretty clear in general.  But while the focus would naturally shift to physical reasons why breastfeeding is less successful for these women (such as delayed onset of mature milk or underdevelopment of the breast), this year’s research points to some non-physical factors at play:

Obesity:  Obesity in adolescence was associated with short breastfeeding duration, but only among low socioeconomic status mothers.

American Journal of Human Biology:  “Women with high pre-pregnant BMI have reduced lactation duration that is mediated by lack of comfort/confidence with one’s body

Oxford University Press:  Among primiparae (first time moms), high BMI was associated with nearly double the risk of early cessation of exclusive breastfeeding, but not among multiparae (second+ time moms) who had previous breastfeeding experience and were of higher socioeconomic status.

These findings suggest that biology is not necessarily destiny – modifiable factors like extra support might make a difference.

There are many unanswered questions in this area, and I hope that research in 2013 continues to provide answers.

4 thoughts on “Science You Can Use: Some obese women struggle with breastfeeding, but new research suggests it’s not all about physiology.

  1. I am an obese mother who still nurses a 3.5 year old (though I haven’t made milk for the last few months, she still is nursing).
    I will say that one very discouraging thing about being an obese nursing mother is the complete lack of nursing tops available in larger sizes. Motherhood maternity sells plus sized maternity clothes, but not plus sized nursing wear. Do they expect that our uterus works just fine, but not our breasts? That’s just one of the obstacles. I finally discovered that I didn’t need a nursing shirt to nurse my child, but I didn’t know that at first.
    Another awkward thing about nursing as an obese mother is that nursing on the go makes it even more difficult to get around (squeezing between shopping racks, etc). It feels weird to take up any more space, sometimes, because of course while your child is nursing, it feels like an extension of yourself and makes you feel even larger.
    Even though I didn’t receive a lot of support from our healthcare providers in the beginning and we did have a little bit of a rough start (was told that I had to supplement at 2 weeks when my child wasn’t up to birth weight, though she was gaining), I am very glad that my spouse was supportive and I made my goal of 2 yeears and then my goal of 3 years.


  2. I found this really great resource that answers all kinds of questions about exposures during pregnancy and breastfeeding. The answer questions about illness, medication, disease, occupational exposures, hair dye, etc. They are very friendly and helpful. You can call them for free at 800-733-4727.


  3. I completely agree with first post also being a bigger woman its tough because of larger breast.. i have to hold my breast in order for baby to latch. and he is still having latching problems… Not sure how I will handle that as there are no bf’ing tops to hold me.. any advice?


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s